Identical Twins, One Gun, One Dead

Close-up of a handgun muzzle with smoke swirling from the barrel
Photo: Christopher Slesarchik / Shutterstock

A 16-year-old in Washington, D.C., is charged as an adult with murder in the shooting death of his identical twin brother, after a fight that court documents say began when the victim went into his room and touched his things.

Story Snapshot

  • Police say Jabrell Young, 16, was shot in his family’s Northeast D.C. home on Sunday, October 25, and died at the scene.
  • His twin, Jamari Young, was arrested on Wednesday, November 18, and charged as an adult with second-degree murder while armed.
  • A judge ordered Jamari held without bond on Thursday, November 19.
  • The boys’ mother says the shooting was an accident; Jamari is accused, not convicted.

Police Identify Victim And Charge Twin Brother

Jamari Young is accused of killing his identical twin, Jabrell. His family says it was an accident. “This is an accident. This is an accident,” their mother told reporters outside court. She said, “My son and his brother are best friends. They love each other.” An aunt said Jamari was terrified and did not mean to shoot his brother.

Police say officers were called to the 200 block of 46th Street Northeast at about 8:30 a.m. on Sunday, October 25. According to court documents, they found Jabrell unconscious and not breathing in the basement with two gunshot wounds to the chest. He was pronounced dead at the home. Relatives said he died in his mother’s arms. Police describe the case as domestic, meaning it happened inside the family.

What Court Records Describe

According to court documents, a witness heard arguing in the basement and found the twins “tussling.” The witness said Jamari was “challenging Jabrell about coming into [his] room and touching his things.” The witness, who tried to pull them apart, told police, “It was in Jamari’s hand,” and “it went off.”

Court documents say Jamari then cried out that he did not mean to and that the gun went off, and said, “I’m sorry, Ma!” According to reports, security cameras showed him walking, then running, out of the neighborhood. Police found two .45-caliber shell casings in the house but have not recovered the weapon. Officers also found a 9 mm pistol wrapped in a blanket under a car outside. Testing linked that gun to a shooting in July, according to reports. Police have not said whether it was used in Jabrell’s death.

The Arrest And The Charge

Police say Jamari walked into the Seventh District station on Wednesday, November 18, and surrendered to a regional fugitive task force under a D.C. Superior Court arrest warrant. Family members said they turned him in. His mother said he did not come forward sooner because “he was scared.”

Jamari is charged with second-degree murder while armed. Second-degree murder means a killing done with malice but without advance planning. He is charged as an adult under Title 16, a D.C. law that lets 16- and 17-year-olds accused of certain violent crimes, such as murder, be tried in adult court. At his first court appearance on Thursday, November 19, a judge ordered him held without bond. A charge is not a finding of guilt.

A Family Torn Apart

The boys’ mother has said she is being treated “like I’m the suspect.” She said investigators took her electronic devices. In a fundraiser, she wrote that Jamari was “being portrayed in a way that could put his life in danger.”

One twin is dead, and the other is jailed and facing an adult murder charge. Police have not said who owned the gun that fired the fatal shots or how it got into the home. The case moves forward in D.C. Superior Court, where prosecutors must prove the charge and the family maintains the gun went off by accident.

Sources:

foxnews.com, mpdc.dc.gov, fox5dc.com