Helpless Girl DIES On Bus — Who The Bus BOSS Blamed

Yellow school bus driving on a suburban street
Photo: Stuart Monk / Shutterstock

Hours after a 7-year-old Cincinnati girl died on her school bus, the superintendent told her board that the bus company’s own CEO said staff had not strapped the girl in properly, newly released emails show.

Story Snapshot

  • Ngone Talla, 7, used a wheelchair and could not speak. She was found unresponsive on her First Student bus on September 16 and died that day.
  • That night, Superintendent Shauna Murphy wrote that First Student’s CEO told her the driver and monitor “did not strap her on appropriately, causing her death.”
  • First Student says the call came before any investigation, and that the email’s description does not match the coroner’s later findings.
  • The coroner ruled the death an accident. No one has been charged.

What the Emails Say

The emails were released on Friday, November 13, after a local news station filed a public records request. They show what Cincinnati Public Schools leaders were told on the night Ngone died. They matter because the district’s first account of her death came from the bus company itself, and it blamed the company’s own staff.

At 8:03 p.m. on Wednesday, September 16, First Student CEO John Kenning left Murphy a voicemail. “We have a tragic event going on,” he said. First Student is the private company the district pays to run its buses. At 8:39 p.m., Murphy emailed the school board. She wrote that Kenning told her the driver and monitor “did not strap her on appropriately, causing her death.”

First Student and the District Respond

First Student disputes how that call has been described. The company said its CEO called the superintendent right away that evening, before any investigation had started and when many facts were unknown. It said the email’s description does not reflect what happened or the coroner’s later findings. The company said it is cooperating fully with authorities and working with the district. It preserved the bus video and gave it to Cincinnati police.

The district said Murphy’s email reflected what it knew that evening. It called Ngone “a beloved child.” The school board said a thorough review is needed and that it will not rush to judgment. Ngone’s family declined to comment.

What the Coroner Found

The Hamilton County Coroner’s Office ruled the cause of death positional asphyxiation. That means her breathing was cut off by the position of her body. The manner of death was ruled an accident.

According to the autopsy, Ngone was in her wheelchair, held by a five-point seatbelt, which crosses the shoulders, waist and legs. As she moved her arms and legs, which was part of her condition, she slid partly off the seat and her upper body turned. The belt pressed on her neck and chin. The report also notes a “delay in care” before anyone called 911.

The Bus Ride Home

Ngone attended Roselawn Condon School. She had Joubert syndrome, a rare brain disorder, and cerebral palsy, which affects movement. She rode the bus home to the family’s house in the Northside neighborhood.

Her father said the bus sat outside their home for 10 to 15 minutes before anyone told the family anything. Her 12-year-old sister, Marema, often helped bring Ngone off the bus. She said she found her sister not breathing in her wheelchair. Her father called 911 at about 5:03 p.m. He said the monitor that day was someone the family had never seen.

Where Things Stand

No one has been charged in Ngone’s death. Police have the bus video, and authorities are still investigating. Police have not said whether they suspect a crime. The district has not said whether the monitor was a regular employee or a substitute.

Sources:

fox19.com, wcpo.com, wlwt.com, wlwt.com, dayton247now.com