A federal judge has delivered a resounding victory for religious liberty, ruling that an Idaho charter school’s cancellation of a church’s facility lease violated First Amendment protections in a landmark decision that strengthens constitutional safeguards against government discrimination.
Story Highlights
- Chief U.S. District Court Judge David Nye ruled Sage International School violated Truth Family Bible Church’s First Amendment rights by canceling their gymnasium lease
- The lease cancellation occurred when the charter school pursued $15 million in public bond financing, with attorneys claiming the church arrangement violated Idaho’s Blaine Amendment
- Idaho Attorney General Raúl Labrador intervened supporting the church, declaring government agencies cannot discriminate against religious organizations
- Judge characterized the constitutional concerns as a “lapse in judgment,” noting the church would only incidentally benefit from bond-improved facilities
Federal Court Delivers Constitutional Victory
Chief U.S. District Court Judge David Nye delivered a decisive ruling protecting religious organizations from government discrimination when he determined that Sage International School violated Truth Family Bible Church’s constitutional rights. The Baptist congregation had successfully rented the Middleton, Idaho charter school’s gymnasium for Sunday services until attorneys flagged the arrangement as potentially problematic under state constitutional provisions. Judge Nye firmly rejected this reasoning, emphasizing that terminating the lease violated multiple First Amendment protections including Free Exercise, Establishment, and Free Speech clauses.
The case originated when Sage International School pursued approximately $15 million in bonds through the Idaho Housing and Finance Association for facility upgrades. IHFA attorneys raised concerns about Idaho’s Blaine Amendment, which prohibits religious organizations from receiving taxpayer resources, leading to the church’s lease cancellation. Truth Family Bible Church, described as a new congregation that began as a home Bible study, found their established worship arrangement suddenly terminated despite the indirect nature of any potential public benefit.
State Officials Champion Religious Rights
Idaho Attorney General Raúl Labrador intervened decisively on behalf of the church, with his spokesperson declaring that “Government agencies cannot discriminate against religious organizations simply because they’re religious.” This intervention demonstrates strong state-level commitment to protecting constitutional rights and preventing selective enforcement of regulations against faith-based organizations. Labrador’s involvement signals broader recognition that religious liberty requires active defense against bureaucratic overreach, particularly when government officials attempt to use technical interpretations to exclude religious organizations from equal treatment.
Judge Nye characterized the Blaine Amendment concerns as a “lapse in judgment,” noting that Truth Family Bible Church would have “only incidentally benefited from the bond-improved facilities” without receiving direct funding. An IHFA spokesperson acknowledged the ruling’s importance, stating they “welcome the legal clarity the court’s ruling provides, helping to ensure that this type of issue doesn’t arise in the future.” This admission suggests previous uncertainty about applying constitutional restrictions may have led to unnecessary discrimination against religious organizations seeking standard facility rental arrangements.
Broader Implications for Religious Liberty
This ruling aligns with recent Supreme Court trends favoring religious organizations’ equal access to generally available public benefits, reinforcing constitutional protections against government discrimination based on religious status. The decision establishes important precedent for charter schools nationwide that rent facilities to religious organizations, clarifying that indirect benefits through facility improvements do not constitute prohibited government aid to religion. Truth Family Bible Church’s victory demonstrates that courts increasingly recognize the difference between direct funding of religious activities and equal treatment in standard business arrangements.
Federal judge rules public charter school violated church's First Amendment rights https://t.co/beFzffPCLo
— Fox News Politics (@foxnewspolitics) October 1, 2025
The case highlights ongoing tensions between state Blaine Amendments and federal constitutional protections, with federal courts consistently prioritizing First Amendment rights over restrictive state interpretations. This landmark decision provides crucial legal clarity protecting religious congregations seeking affordable meeting spaces while ensuring charter schools can maintain facility rental relationships without fear of constitutional violations. Truth Family Bible Church continues holding Sunday services at another school’s gymnasium, but this ruling secures their right to equal treatment in future facility arrangements.
Sources:
Federal judge rules public charter school violated church’s First Amendment rights
Federal judge sides with Idaho church in Blaine Amendment lawsuit
Religious charter schools case
